Plainly Local

Local businesses, no chains · November 2026 figures

The car rental agencies for accident replacement vehicle of Australia

As of November 2026, the three most fairly rated local car rental agencies for accident replacement vehicle in Australia on Plainly Local, with chains left out, are Redline Car Hire QLD (5.0 from 61 Google reviews), Redline Car Hire (4.9 from 287 Google reviews) and Asset Rentals (4.9 from 118 Google reviews).

Car Rental Agencies compared
85
Google reviews
8,104
Median rating
4.3

The car rental agencies for accident replacement vehicle of Australia: the top 10

  1. 2

    Redline Car Hire

    4.9 from 287 Google reviews.

    101 Collins St, Melbourne VIC 3000

    redlinecarhire.com.au

  2. 6

    True Blue Car And Van Rental

    5.0 from 8 Google reviews.

    88 Victoria road Cnr of Victoria road and, Buller St

    02 9191 0324 mytbam.com.au

  3. 7

    Car2You Rentals - Melbourne

    4.7 from 13 Google reviews.

    car2you.com.au

Plainly Local compared 85 car rental agencies in Australia whose own websites list accident replacement vehicle, with 8,104 Google reviews between them. Of these, 10 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.3 from a median of 17 reviews.

Of the car rental agencies compared, the most reviewed is No Birds Car Hire - Woolloomooloo, with 1,098 Google reviews at 4.3.

How this list is ranked

Businesses are ranked as in the fairly rated method, but only those whose name and website each appear in no more than two places in Australia are listed, so chains and franchises are left out. Each needs at least five Google reviews.

A business that shares its name with unrelated businesses elsewhere can be left out by mistake, and being part of a chain says nothing about quality.

The whole method and its rules

Questions

Which local car rental agencies for accident replacement vehicle in Australia, not chains, are the most fairly rated?
As of November 2026, the three most fairly rated local car rental agencies for accident replacement vehicle in Australia on Plainly Local, with chains left out, are Redline Car Hire QLD (5.0 from 61 Google reviews), Redline Car Hire (4.9 from 287 Google reviews) and Asset Rentals (4.9 from 118 Google reviews).
How does Plainly Local rank car rental agencies for accident replacement vehicle in Australia?
Businesses are ranked as in the fairly rated method, but only those whose name and website each appear in no more than two places in Australia are listed, so chains and franchises are left out. Each needs at least five Google reviews. A business that shares its name with unrelated businesses elsewhere can be left out by mistake, and being part of a chain says nothing about quality.
How many car rental agencies for accident replacement vehicle in Australia did Plainly Local compare?
Plainly Local compared 85 car rental agencies in Australia whose own websites list accident replacement vehicle, with 8,104 Google reviews between them. Of these, 10 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.3 from a median of 17 reviews.